On OTR

 

From the Cincinnati Enquirer 05 Apr 2014

From the Cincinnati Enquirer 05 Apr 2014

Italianate: An architectural style familiar to Cincinnatians; to me, this word means history, it means culture and the effect of row after row of rooftops overlooking the city. – David Falk, Cincinnati restaurateur, Huffington Post  

Over-the-Rhine (“über dem Rhein.” in German) is a Cincinnati neighborhood that got its name from the Germans that transformed the area in the mid-1800s from farms and gardens to a vibrant community. Its name came from the fact that residents had to cross the Miami-Erie Canal that separated the neighborhood from downtown. (Today, the former canal is Central Parkway, a large thoroughfare.)

DSC02035

It was this wave of working-class German immigrants that brought Italianate architecture to Cincinnati. This scale-down version of Italian palaces met their needs because there were affordable to build on narrow lots.

At one time, more than 45,000 people lived in Over-the-Rhine (OTR), of which 75% were first or second generation German-Americans. Given the German culture’s love for beer, Cincinnati’s historic brewery district was born, which also employed thousands. OTR also became home to Cincinnati landmarks as Music Hall, Findlay Market, historic churches, Washington Park, Memorial Hall, and more.

DSC02008Many left the neighborhood due to the anti-German sentiment of World War I. Coupled that with Prohibition, OTR changed. Although many Appalachians became residents, the neighborhood remained vibrant. The 1960s brought interstates to urban areas, and OTR became flanked by I-75 and I-71. Suburbia began to grow, and the neighborhood’s demographics continued to change – eventually leaving this neighborhood to the poor.

DSC02047By 2000, the once-proud neighborhood was the poster for urban blight – deteriorating buildings, walls separating, broken windows, unsanitary living quarters, drugs, shootings, and high crime. With an average median income of $10,000 per household, OTR was also the home for many social agencies.

“One of the most dangerous neighborhoods in the country” would be added to a neighborhood that in 1983 received distinction of a historic district listed in the National Register of Historic Places that has significance to other historic neighborhoods as in Savannah (Georgia), Charleston (South Carolina), the French Quarter (New Orleans), and Greenwich Village (New York City).

DSC02043In 2003, Cincinnati Center City Development Corp (3CDC) formed to transform the area. After all, the 360 acres of historic distinction was home to 943 buildings of Italianate architecture from the 19th century. Besides, given the historic distinction, tearing down buildings is not an option – so change became the order.

With 3CDC leading the charge, millions have been spent to rehabilitate the historic neighborhood to restore buildings, renovate Washington Park, improve streetscape, add green space, and develop DSC02050commercial space. Yes – OTR is rapidly changing. Suburban friends of ours recently purchased a building to rehabilitate into their future home.

Last October, a friend and I decided to walk around Over-the-Rhine. Transformation is evident by site of active construction workers and buildings are various stages of restoration. Mixed within the new, social agencies remain to care for the many that remain needy – causing me to wonder where they will go. Nonetheless, vibrancy is returning to this historical, once-vibrant neighborhood. After all, a Graeter’s has also arrived in OTR.

You (Cincinnati) are no longer that embarrassing girlfriend I don’t tell my friends about, insecure and self-conscious. You are alive and breathing in gasps of energy, and I scream my love for you from the Italianate rooftops. David Falk, Cincinnati restaurateur, Huffington Post

On a beautiful day, we walked a lot, saw a lot, and always felt safe. Enjoy the pictures of this historic Cincinnati neighborhood. Any thoughts?

DSC02009

DSC02010
DSC02012

DSC02051
DSC02054
DSC02048
DSC02053
DSC02023
DSC02037

Additional References

About these ads

54 thoughts on “On OTR

  1. It is wonderful to see these areas rejuvenated. I do worry about just exactly what happens to the former residents, though. The ones who can’t afford the spiffy versions.

    I lived on Capitol Hill in the 80’s when it was in transition. There was much disharmony and much adaptability Interesting times.

    • Elyse,
      It seems that developers what this to be a “mixed” neighborhood. Currently, it is … but time will tell what happens in the future. As you know, problems don’t go way, they move.

  2. Good for you, for getting down and dirty and seeing for yourself. I am not that familiar with your Cinci; just kinda waved to it on my way to Lexington a few times. Never close enough to see the deterioration in buildings and the plight of people in the neighbourhoods touched by social and economic changes to the worst. In many cities, one area gets forgotten while another gets all the attention -they say it is, “better and cheaper to build new” -that translates to miles of cookie-cutter burbs and ump-tine times box stores for the city mice to scurry in and out of.

    • Hudson,
      Forgotten and attention are great words to describe what is going on. I’m one who sees many things as cyclical … thus the burbs renewal is in the future. Meanwhile, much work to do still in OTR, but it is interesting!

  3. My initial thought is maybe you should invest in a property now, Frank. It sounds like this is going to be very hot real estate very soon. Get in on it now before overseas investors get wind of it. They already own most of Manhattan.

  4. Fabulous architecture Frank and I enjoyed that history lesson too. It is always of concern though when the poor and needy are not mentioned in plans to up-market their home areas. They are people too.

  5. I really love hearing about this transformation-in-progress, Frank. I feel like many of the city planners, city and state government agencies, and dedicated individuals from all over the country have finally gotten it straight that urban blight hurts all of us. It takes so much money and work to reinvest in these neighborhoods and restore some gentility, but that’s what I see in these colorful and interesting homes and buildings. They’ve been given a second chance, and I think this time they’ll be fully appreciated. There are parts of Los Angeles that are definitely in this same state of slow recovery. Your photos and walking history tour is really special to see. Thank you for sharing it. :-)

    • Debra,
      Well said. I’ve got the feeling various aspects of urban renewal is happening throughout the country. To me, one of the downside is where do the people go …. I guess other areas with low rent, thus the problems shift.I have another post in the queue about this area.

    • Bulldog,
      OTR is a hotbed of activity … also means many of the problems associated with blight remains at the moment. But the architecture also captures my attention.

  6. Beautiful architecture. It’s so nice seeing communities renovating old buildings rather than demolishing them to build “modern” ones! Lovely walk, Frank! Happy Thursday! :-)

  7. I prefer the old architecture more than the new. The old seems to have more character and tells a story, whereas these mirrored/glass buildings erected today, say nothing to me.

  8. So glad to see this vibrancy coming to Cinci. The history is incredible. I, like some of your other commenters, hope that there will be a workable plan to accommodate the poor.

    • E-Tom,
      I do wonder about those displaced, thus a good question is regarding a plan and/or assistance for those displaced. Currently, I find it interesting that social service agencies are quite noticeable among the construction … so the need is still high in that neighborhood.

  9. It has been quite some time since I visited OTR. Cincy has such a lovely and colorful history. I am happy to see that there is a push to revitalize and hold on to it;)

  10. I love the buildings and the thought of saving it. I worry though that suddenly it is another place the original members of the community will suddenly find themselves pushed out with nowhere to go.

    • Val,
      No question to it is a place in transition, and I believe the community’s goal is to be a socio-economic mix. Prior to the renovation efforts, it was the worst part of the city. Then again, the worst area can (and no doubt will) relocate.

      • Too true Frank. As I work toward restoration in my own life and consider all my opportunities one of the cities I am considering is Detroit (shock I know). But they are undergoing a huge restoration and there is a renaissance underway in many parts of the city, it simply isn’t talked about very much. So I get it, I do.

        • With so much empty, renovation opportunities are abound in Detroit. Then again, with so many pickings, careful selection would be of utmost importance. On the downside, you would miss the humidity.

        • I would miss much, but Dallas isn’t humid it is just Dallas. I would miss my children and grandchildren. That is what airports and planes are for. Right now though I am focused on what is right for me.

        • Absolutely in terms family. In terms of humidity, I know Dallas is not Houston, but Detroit is not Dallas … and I know you like the hot weather!

        • Yes, I do. Yet still, it must come down to doing what is right for me now and for the last working years of my life. So I leave my options open and pick the cities that appeal on levels that include work, balance and things other than heat.

  11. Architecture is so fascinating. Such beautiful craftsmanship. There’s quite a bit of GErman influence here. Some of these are so similar to very small old towns around the state. Rich people would hire German building crews that traveled around building town buildings/courthouses.
    Thanks for the info and pictures – hope the cherishing of old building grows!

    • Mouse,
      No matter the location, architecture from that period is beautiful … and many there are many locations throughout the country getting a facelift … and so many more waiting.

  12. I’m so glad to see you showcasing Over the Rhine as it should be. Cincinnati is a lovely, interesting city. Home to Doris Day and Andy Williams and even Steven Spielberg. yowzaaaa From driving the banks of the Ohio River, to the green neighborhoods that surprise with deer, and the history of the Tafts. Walking with friends from the hotels around Fountain Square, we always end up at a great eatery/bar. Love the murals, the architecture and the cool breeze of the Ohio River. We don’t “fear for our lives” but we are careful.

    • Georgette,
      Thanks so much for sharing your experiences with my city. Nothing like an honest opinion from an outsider. Hope you get a chance to make it to OTR & Findlay Market during the daylight hours!

  13. Pingback: On a Grand Hall | A Frank Angle

Comment with respect.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s