On All-Time Reds

reds-logoOne of the biggest days of the year in Cincinnati is one week away – Opening Day. Although that topic is a post in itself, the official start of the national pastime stimulates a lot of thoughts. Lester’s Legends inspired this post has he is in the early stages of posting his all-time teams for each MLB team.

As a lifelong Cincinnati Reds fan, I contend Reds teams of the 1970s, especially ’75 and ’76 are among the great MLB teams; therefore, players from this era would dominate an all-time Reds team. With that in mind, here’s my 25-man team of 13 batters and 12 pitchers outside of the Big Red Machine era.

1B – Ted Kluszewski
2B – Bid McPhee
SS – Barry Larkin
3B – Chris Sabo
C – Ernie Lombardi
OF – Frank Robinson
OF – Edd Roush
OF – Eric Davis

Bench – Ron Oester (MI), Heinie Groh (3B), Cy Seymour (OF), Vada Pinson (OF), Bubbles Hargrave (C)

SP – Jim Maloney
SP – Jose Rijo
SP – Mario Soto
SP – Bucky Walters
SP – Tom Seaver
P – Paul Derringer
P – Eppa Rixey
P – Noodles Hahn
P – Bob Purkey

RP – John Franco
RP – Rob Dibble
RP – Wayne Granger

Manager – Bill McKechnie


  • The Reds have a strong history with middle infielders, and Brandon Phillips has the potential to be on this team.
  • Reds history is least blessed at third base
  • Baseball Reference the year-by-year lineup
  • List of Reds Mangers
  • Reds history

Reds logo is property of the Cincinnati Reds


8 thoughts on “On All-Time Reds

  1. Nice team Frank. Third base is a position that hasn’t been a strong point for the Cubs outside Ron Santo. Aramis Ramirez has a good shot to make it now though. I did one of these on the message boards for the Cubs three years ago on SN, so I might repost another one for them.


    • David,
      It was interesting to do with the no Big Red Machine players. The Baseball Reference link shows the starting lineups through the years, and wow … 3B was thin. I’ll have to check the Cubs.

      Thanks for visiting!


  2. I had to read it a 2nd time when I did not see Pete Rose and Tony Perez not on it. And Yes the Big Red Machine would dominate it, It is still a very good team


    • Larry,
      The dominance of the Big Red Machine is why I did it. Beieve it or not, I still considered Rose since he started in 1963.

      Since you had to read it a second time to catch my premise, I’ll accent the font on the post.

      Thanks Larry!


    • Larry,
      Great question. I would say a good chance. After all, I see that I didn’t include a DH on that team, so I could work one in on a technicality. Yet, who knows …. maybe Votto’s stats will become one of the elites. Thanks for digging into my archives.


Comment with respect.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s